BrainKing - Fout #1945

Maker: dp13
(toon meldingen van deze gebruiker)

Fout #1945 (terug naar de lijst met Storingen)

Titel:	Move Issue
Beschrijving:	I am setting this bug as highest priority as many users can exploit this bug to win games. Suppose I have 1 piece at 19 & 3 pieces at 22...now I roll a dice of 6+3... after clicking piece at 19 url wud be... http://brainking.com/en/ShowMove?g=4193730&m=19 now I edit the url to http://brainking.com/en/ShowMove?g=4193730&m=19222222 and click on Move button...all my pieces are off... this bug is present for all types BackGammon games...pls fix it...
URL:	ShowGame?g=4193730
Useragent:	Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.9.1.3) Gecko/20090824 Firefox/3.5.3 (.NET CLR 3.5.30729)
Taal versie:

Commentaar:

Pedro Martínez

4. april 2010, 21:44:56

Status gewijzigd in "gesloten".

Fixed.

playBunny

4. april 2010, 20:46:52

Please don't fix this bug until the "Every-roll's-a-double" tournament is finished. *552* (rofl)

Pedro Martínez

23. maart 2010, 07:28:30

Já to sem napíšu ještě česky, aby bylo jasné, o co jde: ručním přepisem URL řádku lze dosáhnout toho, že i případě, kdy na kostkách padnou různá čísla, je možné udělat 4 tahy kameny. Viz tato hra (téměř každý tah):
http://brainking.com/cz/ShowGame?g=4525428

Pedro Martínez

20. januari 2010, 02:51:43

Pedro Martínez

11. december 2009, 02:42:03

Just wanting this one to stay near the top of the list of bugs.

earldrake

13. november 2009, 05:44:15

This has been an issue for more than a year. I may be able to find an old game where my opponent figured this out and showed it to me.

Pedro Martínez

9. november 2009, 17:48:31

OK. That's one hell of a serious bug.

dp13

9. november 2009, 17:34:12

The move mentioned in the previous post is not valid anymore...but I submitted a new move...
http://brainking.com/en/ShowMove?g=4274138&m=13131313

Please check it & revert the move if possible...as I submitted the move only for testing...

Pedro Martínez

9. november 2009, 02:59:24

Do submit the move so it is clear if it works or not.

dp13

7. november 2009, 12:47:29

Please chk the image below...
http://img81.imageshack.us/img81/9519/screenshothq.jpg

If I submit the move below then what can happen...
http://brainking.com/en/ShowMove?g=4274138&m=06061719

I think the problem is clear now...pls chk it...thnx...

dp13

21. september 2009, 21:10:03

I think u r not getting the exact problem...so re-explaining...

after editing the url I hit enter in the address bar...so the changes reflected in the board...thr was no validation of the move...so when I clicked the Move button it accepted the illegal move & my move was submitted...hope this is clear now...

u can replicate the problem in any type of BackGammon game...

pauloaguia

21. september 2009, 18:31:04

Status gewijzigd in "open".

I'm not really sure about this but I think that if you submited such a move it ouldn't be accepted. By entering that URL you will effectively see the board altered as you suggested but when clicking submit it won't be validated and nothing happens (the game continues on your turn).

But I'm not sure if it is like this for this particular action...